Sunday, May 18, 2008

challenged.

friends, i am currently in the midst of a challenge.
this challenge has been with me since january.
this challenge was unexpected and, to be honest, unwelcomed.
this challenge has made me question my ability to teach and forced me to examine my patience and love towards others.

this challenge is a six-year-old girl.

as i type and re-read that, i feel like i should just turn in my teaching credential because i don't like feeling this way towards a child. as a teacher, isn't it my job to educate, nurture, support, build up and motivate every young person that enters my door? my challenge lies in the fact that i want to throw up my hands and move on in each of those areas. i want to give up on educating, nurturing, supporting, building up and motivating this one young person.

and that makes me feel a little sick in my stomach.
but it's how i feel.
and i'm having trouble reconciling these two competing trains of thought.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

i suppose i should back-up a little bit to fill you in. in december of this school year, my principal came to me and mentioned a situation with a colleague of mine and a student in her class (this is the student). the mother was unhappy with my colleague for a variety of reasons and requested a transfer. at the time, i had an opening in my class and i was informed that, come january, this student would be a part of my class.
i'd heard a lot about this student from my colleague and, sadly, was expecting the worst based on her horror stories. i decided, over the winter vacation, to put aside what i'd heard and i would try be the best darn teacher this girl ever had. i would support her and do all the things my colleague neglected to do.
january rolled around and this student joined my class. as with any new student(s), the first days and weeks are good...everyone is still feeling each other out and we're all on our best behavior (teachers, included). and in those idealized early days, i made the effort to be whatever this child needed. i supported, made modifications and 'cut her some slack' because she was new to life in b-07.
that was in january.
in the last five (!) months, i have not kept my promise to myself and this student. i have let myself fall into a pattern of indifference, frustration and negative feedback. i have allowed the behavior of one child affect the way i interact with the rest of my students and change the dynamics we had from september to december.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

at this point in the year, with four short weeks to go, i have been reflecting on this past year, specifically in regards to my teaching and interacting with my students.
this reflection was initiated by a comment made in passing by my husband.
a few days ago, during one of our long-distance phone conversations where i was 'discussing' (also known as: complaining) about my day, he mentioned that my attitude towards teaching had changed since she came into b-07. he recalled early in the year when i was excited about the possibilities of these little scholars and all of the growth we would make during this first grade year.
after we hung up, i sat for awhile and considered what he said. i agreed with everything he said but i was, and still am, caught up in how to make it better. admitting defeat and throwing up my hands is not what i'm about - i am a planner, a finisher, a nagger - and i keep going until something is done.
with this student, i feel like i am still trying to break ground and get the ball rolling. academically, she is unmotivated, cannot complete work independently, and needs constant reminders to stay on task. socially, she is used to being babied, bullies other students and does not respect my authority.
this child has been tested for learning difficulties and, based on the numerous tests and reports from our school psychologist and resource teacher, did not qualify for any additional services. this child is capable of reading - but won't participate. this child does not listen during lessons and then misses problems on tests. this child is so capable...but doesn't use all of the skills and resources she has available to her.
it literally makes me want to bang my head on a wall or kidney-shaped table.

here comes the point in this rambling where i appeal to you, blog friends. this post would be super depressing if i just left it with all these negative feelings and defeatist attitudes. my question for you is this:
how can you motivate a seemingly unmotivated child to want to learn?

it's a big question, i know. and it is one i have been wrestling with for the last few months. i don't know of all your experiences, but maybe some of you know about children like this. maybe you have worked with a child like this, or a sibling of yours was a child like this or maybe even you were a child like this? :)

this young girl is being 'passed on' to second grade for some incredibly stupid reasons that are completely out of my control. and, as long as she is a super cheetah in my class, i feel like i need to do whatever i can. but my bag of tricks is just about empty.

thanks to you who read this long-winded ramble. and extra thanks to those who can offer a word of advice or something.

happy monday/week to you all. i am off to bed to prepare for another busy, but hopefully less challenging, day with my little scholars. :)

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi Jill,
I don't remember how I found your blog, but have been checking in on you for a while now. I am a second year, fifth grade teacher and enjoy reading about other new teacher's experiences.
Although I teach fifth grade and my struggles are different, I had a very difficult class last year. I found it challenging to not punish the whole class, but to also dicipline those 5 or 6 students who decided not to behave. I had to get creative. Here is one idea that came to mind:
What does this student enjoy? Maybe start some sort of reward chart, for example if she earns 10 stickers or stamps she can turn it in for a prize or time on the computer, whatever it is she likes. If you do this, at the beginning, reward her for every effort she makes to get her going, after she has earned her "prize" a couple times, tell her she has to work even harder, but not too much that she gets frustrated.
I'm guessing her parents are not very involved or place the blame on her teachers for her not paying attention. If not, ask them to come sit with her for a day, so they can see what you are dealing with and figure a way out to reward her at home if she has a good day.
Th eonly hard part is....how do you start this system with just one student. It isn't fair to those who have been behaving and workin ghard all year to watch this girl get rewarded for just starting to put in effort. Maybe work out a way to give her stickers or points at the end of the day and keep a little tally on a sheet of paper.
Good luck! Hang in there, everything happens for a reason right? This girl was meant to be with you for some reason :)

Anonymous said...

hi friend...

first, i'm sorry, but banging your head on a kidney shaped table killed me.

i feel your pain/struggle with this kid...sounds like she's starting early for middle school. i have multiple kids like this, and i know how totally helpless it makes you feel as an educator who cares about kids.

i agree wholehartedly with the advice above. what makes this kid tick? my classroom literally transformed when i started using stamps to mark progress...even 12 year olds were vying for a stamp. it's been great. i've done all kinds of things to motivate kids: made a chris brown cd, brought chocolate, allowed a kid to listen to her ipod, etc. i would try to find something like that and see if it works.

are her parents supportive? can you have an open and honest conversation with them, perhaps with the support of your principal, and share your fears. obviously, this child is on a path of being unsuccessful...many parents need to hear the fact that not only are you frustrated, you're afraid for her future.

other than that---and this is a direct lesson/quote from MY evaluator---"you can't make chicken salad when all you have is chicken sh**". at some point, you have to take the guilt/pressure off of yourself. as much as you want to create something amazng for this kid, they have to want it. school is all about learning personal responsibility. don't let one kid's apathy ruin the rest of the super cheetahs.

i know how compassionate, kind and amazing you are (as a teacher and a friend!) so i have no doubt you're giving this your all. remember...sometimes all we can do is plant a seed. and someday, this little girl may look back and see your efforts and be glad that someone believed in her.

love and miss you...let's hang out while we're off work!

xo